The Farmer's Dog vs Ollie: Which Fresh Food Is Better for Older Dogs?

We may earn a commission if you buy through our links, at no cost to you. How we make money.

The short answer

They cost about the same and both are vet-formulated fresh food. Pick The Farmer's Dog if your senior dog has health issues you want the plan built around; pick Ollie for more recipe variety, smaller single-day packs and a cheaper half-fresh option.

Quick verdict

It's close. Both are frozen, vet-formulated fresh food delivered on a subscription, at similar prices. The difference is in the details that matter for older dogs.

Best for dogs with health issuesThe Farmer's DogPlans are tailored around health concerns, with a simple four-recipe menu.Skip it if: your dog is fussy and needs variety, or your freezer is small.See The Farmer's Dog
Best for variety and flexibilityOllieFive recipes, single-day packs and a half-fresh plan to cut the cost.Skip it if: you want the plan built around a specific health condition.See Ollie
[SP: if you can, order both starter boxes. Photos of the packs and your dog’s reaction are the strongest thing this page can have.]

The Farmer’s Dog vs Ollie at a glance

The Farmer’s Dog Ollie
Food type Fresh, frozen Fresh, frozen (plus baked option)
Recipes 4: turkey, beef, chicken, pork 5: beef, chicken, lamb, pork, turkey
Plans Full fresh Full fresh or half fresh
Packaging Packs hold up to 4 days of food One day of food per pack
Formulated by Board-certified veterinary nutritionists Vet-crafted, meets AAFCO standards
Senior-specific recipe No (portions tailored to age and weight) No (portions tailored to age and weight)
Starter offer [TODO: check on launch day] 50% off the first box (at time of writing)

Price

Both are premium-priced: expect several times the cost of kibble. Neither is consistently cheaper. These per-day examples come from Ollie’s own comparison page, so treat them as a starting point, not a neutral test:

Dog size (example) Ollie The Farmer’s Dog
3 lb $1.35/day $1.35/day
25 lb $3.16/day $2.62/day
60 lb $4.78/day $4.85/day
100 lb $6.72/day $7.42/day

Prices change and depend on your dog’s weight, activity and recipe. Get a quote from both before deciding. If cost is the sticking point, Ollie’s half-fresh plan (fresh food as a topper over your current food) is the cheapest way to try fresh food.

[TODO: get our own quotes for a 10-year-old, 30 lb dog from both sites and add them with the date.]

Ingredients and recipes for older dogs

Both use whole meats and vegetables you can recognize, cooked gently and frozen. For older dogs, two differences stand out:

  • Fat levels. Senior dogs often need fewer calories. Ollie’s chicken recipe is notably low in fat (about 3%), while the beef recipes from both brands are richer. If your dog is overweight or has a history of pancreatitis, ask your vet which fat level is right.
  • Variety. Ollie’s five recipes, including lamb, give more options for dogs that get bored or have a protein sensitivity.

The Farmer’s Dog leans on customization instead: you tell it about your dog’s health concerns when you sign up, and it builds the plan around them.

Portioning and weight control

This is where fresh food can really help an older dog. Both brands send pre-portioned packs based on your dog’s weight, age and activity, which takes the guesswork out of feeding and makes it easier to keep a senior dog lean. Ollie’s one-day packs are the simplest to use; The Farmer’s Dog’s larger packs mean you measure out each meal.

Delivery, packaging and freezer space

Both ship frozen with dry ice and need about 24 hours in the fridge to thaw. Ollie’s smaller packs fit more easily in a crowded freezer. Both let you change delivery frequency, pause or cancel online.

Things to know before you buy

  • A lawsuit filed in April 2026 (Trott v. The Farmer’s Dog) alleges that some recipes contain more fat than marketed. The company disputes it and there has been no ruling. [TODO: check status before publishing.]
  • AAFCO doesn’t approve foods. “Meets AAFCO standards” means the recipe is formulated to meet its nutrient profiles for a stated life stage.

Which should you choose?

Choose The Farmer’s Dog if your senior dog has health concerns you want the plan built around, and you like a short, simple menu.

Choose Ollie if your dog is fussy or protein-sensitive, you want smaller single-day packs, or you’d like to start with the half-fresh plan to keep costs down.

Either way, switch gradually over about a week and weigh your dog every few weeks for the first two months.

Frequently asked questions

Is The Farmer's Dog or Ollie cheaper?

Neither is consistently cheaper. In Ollie's own published examples, Ollie was cheaper for a 100 lb dog and more expensive for a 25 lb dog, and roughly equal for very small and 60 lb dogs. Get a quote from both for your dog's weight and activity.

Which is better for a senior dog with a sensitive stomach?

Both use short ingredient lists of whole meats and vegetables. Ollie's chicken recipe is the lowest in fat of the main recipes we compared, which can suit dogs that need a lighter diet; ask your vet which fat level suits your dog.

Can I switch from kibble to fresh food at once?

It's better to switch gradually over about a week, mixing increasing amounts of fresh food into the old food. Senior dogs' digestion can be more sensitive to sudden changes.

Do The Farmer's Dog or Ollie make a senior recipe?

Neither sells a separate senior formula. Both portion each plan to your dog's age, weight and activity, which matters more for older dogs that are prone to weight gain.

Sources

  1. Ollie: Ollie vs The Farmer's Dog (brand comparison page)
  2. Dogster: Ollie vs The Farmer's Dog
  3. Webvet: The Farmer's Dog vs Ollie vs Freshpet vs JustFoodForDogs
Written by [Owner name] · Founder and editor

[Two sentences: who you are and why you started this site.]

Reviewed by [Vet name], DVM · Veterinary reviewer

[Licensed veterinarian. Years in practice, focus area, state of license.]

Keep reading